[PATCH] Improve Testing Organization #330
Merged
Conversation
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
…n of tests (- WIP #199 -) Additions with file pytest.ini: - added config for pytest as per #199 Additions with file tests/run_selective.py: - implemented tool to allow selective test running as per #199 Changes in file Makefile: - re-organized targets to allow more selective testing as per #199 - introduced logic to use pytest by default if `TESTS_USE_PYTEST` is defined Changes in file pyproject.toml: - updated to include early test-reoganization config Changes in file tests/__init__.py: - refactored as discussed in #199 Changes in file tests/context.py: - added decorator for marking test suites without requiring pytest Changes in file tests/test_basic.py: - marked tests with meta tags Changes in file tests/test_build.py: - marked tests with meta tags Changes in file tests/test_deps.py: - marked tests with meta tags Changes in file tests/test_exceptions.py: - marked tests with meta tags Changes in file tests/test_fuzz.py: - marked tests with meta tags - made tests optional and simpler to skip outside CI Changes in file tests/test_hear_cleanup.py: - marked tests with meta tags Changes in file tests/test_hear_data_processing.py: - marked tests with meta tags Changes in file tests/test_hear_keyboard_interrupt.py: - marked tests with meta tags Changes in file tests/test_hear_server.py: - marked tests with meta tags Changes in file tests/test_hear_server_activate.py: - marked tests with meta tags Changes in file tests/test_install_requires.py: - marked tests with meta tags Changes in file tests/test_manifest.py: - marked tests with meta tags Changes in file tests/test_usage.py: - marked tests with meta tags
Changes in file tests/__init__.py: - Resolved #232
…273 Changes in file docs/utils.py: - improved validation slightly - added new doctest for changes
Fix 1 of 3 for YAML lint
Fix 2 of 3 for YAML Lint
Fix 3 of 3 for YAML Lint
Changes in file .ast-grep/multicast-rule-check-test-documentation.yml: utils:
Additions with file .ast-grep/multicast-rule-check-class-has-documentation.yml: Unknown Additions Additions with file .ast-grep/multicast-rule-has-module-documentation.yml: Unknown Additions Changes in file .ast-grep/multicast-rule-check-documentation.yml: Unknown Changes Changes in file .ast-grep/multicast-rule-check-test-documentation.yml: rule: utils: Changes in file .ast-grep/multicast-rule-enforce-testcase-format.yml: rule: Changes in file .ast-grep/multicast-rule-exception-handling-pattern.yml: Unknown Changes Changes in file .ast-grep/multicast-rule-require-docstring-testing.yml: rule: Changes in file .ast-grep/multicast-rule-require-docstring.yml: Unknown Changes Changes in file .ast-grep/multicast-rule-require-test-fixtures.yml: rule: Changes in file .ast-grep/multicast-rule-server-implementation-pattern.yml: rule: Changes in file .ast-grep/multicast-rule-test-class-naming-pattern.yml: rule: Changes in file .ast-grep/multicast-rule-udp-client-implementation-pattern.yml: rule: Changes in file .ast-grep/multicast-rule-validate-method-docstring.yml: rule: Changes in file .ast-grep/multicast-rule-verify-test-naming.yml: Unknown Changes
Changes in file .ast-grep/rules/multicast-rule-has-module-documentation.yml: minor tweak. Changes in file .ast-grep/utils/YAML/gha/job-body.yml: Removed trailing space Changes in file .ast-grep/utils/YAML/gha/job-conditional.yml: removed trailing space
Additions with file .ast-grep/rules/multicast-rule-require-doctests-in-docstrings.yml: - added new rule to ensure doctests in docstrings. Changes in file .ast-grep/rules/multicast-rule-check-test-documentation.yml: - minor changes. Changes in file .ast-grep/utils/python/test.yml: - refactored for maintainability
Co-authored-by: coderabbitai[bot] <136622811+coderabbitai[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
Changes in file .coderabbit.yaml: - adds BEEN_PART_AGREEMENT - adds COMMA_COMPOUND_SENTENCE - adds EN_COMPOUND_ADJECTIVE_INTERNAL
Changes in file .coderabbit.yaml: - enabled a bunch more rules
Co-authored-by: coderabbitai[bot] <136622811+coderabbitai[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
Changes in file docs/utils.py: - use only tabs for indentation
def _validate_git_ref(ref: str) -> str:
Changes in file docs/utils.py: Unknown Changes
Co-authored-by: coderabbitai[bot] <136622811+coderabbitai[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
Changes in file .coderabbit.yaml: - added comments for languagetool config rule groupings
Changes in file requirements.txt: - version bump for comment Changes in file setup.cfg: - related changes Changes in file tests/requirements.txt: - version bump as possible fix for #299
Update tests/__init__.py
Changes in file multicast/hear.py: def handle(self): Changes in file multicast/recv.py: def joinstep(groups, port, iface=None, bind_group=None, isock=None):
Changes in file multicast/recv.py: - Added details to doctests to sumarize complex doctest test - rolled back functional changes to joinstep. See #317
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
reactive-firewall
temporarily deployed
to
Experimenting
GitHub Actions
Inactive
10 tasks
This was referenced May 3, 2025
reactive-firewall
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
May 4, 2025
…bringing together improvements from over 40 previous PRs and addressing over 40 distinct issues. It serves as a comprehensive preparation for future development, establishing strong foundations for the upcoming 2.1 version.
These changes aim to enhance code quality, enforce best practices, and streamline CI/CD processes.
---
- **Files Changed**: 100 files across 10 directories
- **Code Volume**: 4,905 lines added, 1,059 lines deleted
- **Impact Scope**:
- Core Python Files: 8 files (1,370 lines added, 447 lines deleted)
- Documentation: 12 files (425 lines added, 145 lines deleted)
- Configuration: 80 files (3,110+ lines added, ~467 lines deleted)
- **Issue Resolution**: Closes 44+ distinct issues
- **PR Consolidation**: Supersedes 42+ previous PRs
- **Milestone**: Concludes "Pre-Version 2.1 Chores" (milestone/13)
<!-- This is an auto-generated comment: release notes by coderabbit.ai -->
- **New Features**
- Introduced extensive static analysis and linting rule configurations for Python and YAML, enforcing documentation, naming conventions, code style, and GitHub Actions workflow patterns.
- Added new GitHub Actions workflows for Flake8 and ShellCheck, and a continuous deployment workflow for PyPI publishing.
- Implemented custom GitHub Actions for artifact management and pip upgrades on Windows.
- Enhanced Makefile with new branding, improved build/install/test targets, and better environment compatibility.
- Added a comprehensive CI/CD output formatting tool for GitHub Actions.
- **Bug Fixes**
- Improved error handling, logging, and validation across core modules (`multicast`, `env`, `exceptions`, `recv`, `hear`, `send`, `skt`).
- Standardized string literals and exception variable naming for clarity and consistency.
- **Documentation**
- Expanded CI and environment configuration documentation, including new badges, usage examples, and copyright/license.
- Improved docstrings, exception guides, and FAQ with clearer examples and error handling.
- **Chores**
- Updated configuration files for coverage, pytest, and dependencies.
- Enhanced `.gitignore` and labeling configuration for better project maintenance.
- Added and updated test scripts and test suite organization for improved coverage and grouping.
- **Style**
- Refactored codebase for consistent string usage, formatting, and logging practices.
- **Tests**
- Reorganized and expanded test suite structure, added dynamic doctest loading, and improved test marker definitions.
- **Refactor**
- Modularized and improved import logic, logging, and internal helper functions for maintainability and robustness.
<!-- end of auto-generated comment: release notes by coderabbit.ai -->
1. **Error Handling Improvements**:
- Refactored exception handling for better traceability and maintainability.
- Introduced `ShutdownCommandReceived` exception for explicit shutdown command handling.
2. **Documentation and Templates**:
- Expanded CI and environment configuration documentation, including new badges, usage examples, and copyright/license.
- Improved docstrings, exception guides, and FAQ with clearer examples and error handling.
- Added new tests for Python versions, workflows for minimal acceptance, and doctests.
- Enhanced test suite structure, added dynamic doctest loading, and improved test marker definitions.
1. **Static Analysis and Linting**:
- Introduced extensive static analysis and linting rule configurations for Python and YAML, enforcing documentation, naming conventions, code style, and GitHub Actions workflow patterns.
- Added 20 new AST-grep rules, including 16 multicast-specific, 3 Python-specific, and 1 GHA-specific rules.
2. **Enhanced GitHub Actions**:
- New workflows for **Flake8**, **Shellcheck**, **CD-PyPi**, and **Makefile Lint**.
- Updates to existing workflows for CI, testing, and code quality checks.
- Improved automation for packaging, testing, and deployment.
3. **Housekeeping and Configuration**:
- Revised `.gitignore` to exclude more development artifacts.
- Enhanced `Makefile` with new targets (`branding`, `purge-coverage-artifacts`), dependencies management, and defaults.
- Improved error handling, logging, and validation across core modules (`multicast`, `env`, `exceptions`, `recv`, `hear`, `send`, `skt`).
- Standardized string literals and exception variable naming for clarity and consistency.
- **Removed Legacy Scripts**: Tools like `tool_checkmake.sh` and `tool_shlock_helper.sh` were replaced with symbolic links or moved under `.github/tools/`.
- **Workflow Adjustments**: Deprecated YAML configurations were replaced or updated with streamlined and secure alternatives.
The changes introduced in the `v2.0.8` release (compared to `v2.0.7`) are extensive and cover multiple areas of the repository.
- **Refactoring Exception Handling:**
- Changed exception variable naming from generic (e.g., `err`, `impErr`) to `_cause` for better traceability.
- Improved `raise from` usage to maintain the original exception context.
- Enhanced clarity and maintainability of error handling across the codebase.
**Impact:**
- These changes improve debugging and maintainability by providing more informative and granular error contexts. They also align with best practices for exception handling.
- **`ShutdownCommandReceived` Exception:**
- Added a new exception class to handle shutdown commands explicitly.
- **AST-Grep Rules for Code Standardization:**
- Introduced `.ast-grep` rules to enforce patterns for `doStep` and `setupArgs` implementations.
- Added utility files for Python-specific AST validation.
**Impact:**
- These features enhance robustness by formalizing error handling for shutdown scenarios.
- Enforcing code patterns ensures consistency in the implementation of core functions.
- Updated exception handling examples in `Exception_Guide.md`.
- Revised FAQ and usage documentation to reflect changes in error handling and function signatures.
- Incremented version references in `docs/conf.py`.
**Impact:**
- Documentation is now more accurate and user-friendly, helping developers understand new conventions and best practices.
- **Improved Coverage for Doctests:**
- Added configurations to include only `multicast/*` files in coverage reports for doctests.
- **Additional Test Cases:**
- Added tests for edge cases and regression.
- **Refinements in Test Utilities:**
- Enhanced logging and output formatting using `cioutput.py`.
**Impact:**
- Enhanced test coverage and detailed reporting improve test reliability and debugging efficiency.
- **New PyPI Deployment Workflow:**
- Introduced `CD-PyPi.yml` workflow for automated publishing of releases to PyPI.
- **Updated CI Workflows:**
- Refined CI configurations to align with Python version updates and GitHub Action improvements.
**Impact:**
- The new deployment pipeline automates release publishing, reducing manual overhead.
- Updated CI workflows leverage the latest tools and methodologies, ensuring compatibility and reliability.
- **Consistency Improvements:**
- Unified function type annotations for better static analysis.
- Refactored redundant or deprecated patterns.
- **Tooling Updates:**
- Introduced `.github/tools/cioutput.py` for consistent CI/CD output formatting.
- Enhanced Makefile with branding and improved task definitions.
**Impact:**
- These changes enhance code quality, readability, and maintainability.
- **Deprecations:**
- Removed obsolete shell scripts and replaced them with symbolic links or consolidated versions.
- **Branding:**
- Added branding to the Makefile for a more professional touch.
**Impact:**
- Streamlining and branding improve the overall developer experience and project presentation.
The `v2.0.8` release introduces significant improvements in exception handling, testing, build automation, and code quality. These changes enhance robustness, maintainability, and developer productivity.
- **Branding**: Added branding to the Makefile for a more professional touch.
- **Technical Debt Reduction**: Refactoring legacy code patterns and standardizing coding practices.
This release represents the culmination of numerous smaller efforts, bringing together improvements from over 40 previous PRs and addressing over 40 distinct issues. It serves as a comprehensive preparation for future development, establishing strong foundations for the upcoming 2.1 version.
The PR includes significant improvements to all core modules of the `multicast` package:
- **hear.py**: Substantial refactoring (348 additions, 53 deletions)
- **env.py**: Enhanced environment handling (263 additions, 51 deletions)
- **exceptions.py**: Improved error handling (189 additions, 50 deletions)
- **recv.py**: Optimized receiving functionality (183 additions, 54 deletions)
- **__init__.py**: Updated package initialization (162 additions, 75 deletions)
A major focus on code quality through:
- **20 New AST-grep Rules**: Including 16 multicast-specific, 3 Python-specific, and 1 GHA-specific rules
- **Code Style Standardization**: Consistent string handling and import organization
- **Documentation Requirements**: New rules for enforcing docstrings and test documentation
Comprehensive improvements to build and test infrastructure:
- **11 Workflow Files Updated**: Including 490+ lines of additions
- **New Workflows**: Added dedicated workflows for Flake8, ShellCheck, and PyPI deployment
- **Testing Improvements**: Enhanced pytest configuration (23 lines added)
- **GitHub Actions**: Multiple action upgrades for security and functionality
Significant documentation enhancements:
- **API Documentation**: Improved docstrings across the codebase
- **Usage Guidelines**: Updated USAGE.md, Exception_Guide.md, and FAQ.md
- **CI Documentation**: Added comprehensive CI.md (49 additions)
- **Documentation Tools**: Major improvements to docs/utils.py (216 additions)
This PR demonstrates systematic progression through:
1. **Dependency Maintenance**: 12 dependency updates via Dependabot
2. **Technical Debt Reduction**: Refactoring legacy code patterns
3. **Standardization**: Implementation of consistent coding standards
4. **Automation**: Enhanced testing and CI/CD capabilities
5. **Documentation**: Comprehensive documentation updates reflecting all changes
1. **Code Quality**: Implementation of robust static analysis rules
2. **Developer Experience**: Improved documentation and error handling
3. **Reliability**: Enhanced testing infrastructure and coverage
4. **Maintainability**: Standardized coding patterns and documentation requirements
5. **Build Process**: Streamlined CI/CD workflows with improved caching
> This release represents the culmination of numerous smaller efforts, bringing together improvements from over 40 previous PRs and addressing over 40 distinct issues. It serves as a comprehensive preparation for future development, establishing strong foundations for the upcoming 2.1 version.
>
> These changes aim to enhance code quality, enforce best practices, and streamline CI/CD processes.
- [x] Closes #134
- [x] Closes #135
- [x] Closes #151
- [x] Closes #165
- [x] Closes #171
- [x] Closes #199
- [x] Closes #202
- [x] Closes #203
- [x] Closes #204
- [x] Closes #205
- [x] Closes #206
- [x] Closes #207
- [x] Closes #210
- [x] Closes #213
- [x] Closes #215
- [x] Closes #222
- [x] Closes #223
- [x] Closes #224
- [x] Closes #275
- [x] Closes #232
- [x] Closes #233
* Contributes to #335
- [x] Closes #239
- [x] Closes #241
- [x] Closes #254
- [x] Closes #255
- [x] Closes #264
- [x] Closes #265
- [x] Closes #266
- [x] Closes #271
- [x] Closes #272
- [x] Closes #273
- [x] Closes #276
- [x] Closes #278
- [x] Closes #279
- [x] Closes #284
- [x] Closes #299
- [x] Closes #317
- [x] Closes #320
- [x] Closes #326
- [x] Closes #332
* Contributes to #338
- [x] Closes #357
- [x] Closes #371
- [x] Closes #365
* Concludes [Pre-Version 2.1 Chores](https://github.com/reactive-firewall/multicast/milestone/13)
* Includes and Supersedes #280
* Includes and Supersedes #285
* Supersedes #286
* Includes and Supersedes #287
* Includes and Supersedes #290
* Includes and Supersedes #291
* Includes and Supersedes #293
* Includes and Supersedes #296
* Includes and Supersedes #305
* Includes and Supersedes #309
* Includes and Supersedes #312
* Includes and Supersedes #318
* Includes and Supersedes #321
* Includes and Supersedes #322
* Includes and Supersedes #323
* Includes and Supersedes #325
* Includes and Supersedes #327
* Includes and Supersedes #328
* Includes and Supersedes #329
* Includes and Supersedes #330
* Includes and Supersedes #334
* Includes and Supersedes #339
* Includes and Supersedes #340
* Includes and Supersedes #341
* Includes and Supersedes #342
* Includes and Supersedes #343
* Includes and Supersedes #344
* Includes and Supersedes #345
* Includes and Supersedes #346
* Includes and Supersedes #347
* Includes and Supersedes #348
* Includes and Supersedes #349
* Includes and Supersedes #351
* Includes and Supersedes #354
* Includes and Supersedes #359
* Includes and Supersedes #361
* Includes and Supersedes #373
* Includes and Supersedes #379
* Includes and Supersedes #384
* Includes and Supersedes #385
* Includes and Supersedes #388
* Includes and Supersedes #389
* Closes #390
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.
Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.
Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.
You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.
Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.
This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.
Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.
Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.
Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Version
v2.0.5Impacted GHI
LanguageToolconfig #206.github/workflows/Tests.yml#266tests/test_usage.py#202tests/test_handling_keyboard_interupt.py#255multicast/exceptions.py#224tests/test_exceptions.py#223tests/test_hear_server.py#279Included PRs
languageToolconfig #293feature-add-import-regression-testing-151#325Summary by CodeRabbit
Comprehensive Patch Notes for
v2.0.5📊 PR Metrics
🔍 Overview
This substantial PR represents a comprehensive overhaul of the testing infrastructure in the multicast project, introducing significant improvements in test organization, code quality, security, and CI workflows. The changes address numerous long-standing issues and incorporate work from multiple previously separate PRs, creating a cohesive approach to testing and quality assurance.
🧪 Testing Framework Improvements
Test Organization and Selection
pytest.iniwith specialized markers for different test categories (MAT, component, documentation, etc.)tests/run_selective.pyto allow running specific test groups and categoriestest-mat,test-extra, andtest-fuzzingTest Quality and Coverage
validateCommandArgsfunction to prevent command injection vulnerabilities (CWE-20)_validate_help_outputintest_usage.py)🛡️ Code Quality and Security Enhancements
AST-grep Rules
Security Improvements
validateCommandArgsfunction prevents null byte injection in command argumentsdef validateCommandArgs(args: list) -> None:
Validates command arguments to ensure they do not contain null characters.
if (args is None) or (args == [None]) or (len(args) <= 0):
raise ValueError("[CWE-1286] args must be an array of positional arguments") from None
for arg in args:
if isinstance(arg, str) and "\x00" in arg:
raise ValueError("[CWE-20] Null characters are not allowed in command arguments.")
Code Style Standardization
🔄 Continuous Integration Updates
PYTHON_DEFAULT,PYTHON_OLD_MIN, etc.)docs/CI.md📝 Documentation and Style Improvements
🔍 Issue Resolution Analysis
This PR addresses a diverse set of issues, demonstrating its comprehensive scope:
tests/test_handling_keyboard_interupt.py#255, v2.0.x Chore - Consider improvements intests/test_hear_server.py#279, etc.).github/workflows/Tests.yml#266, v2.0.x Chore - Consider adding caching for Python dependencies. #278, etc.)tests/test_exceptions.py#223, v2.0.x Chores (3) - improvingmulticast/exceptions.py#224, etc.)LanguageToolconfig #206, Plea for new badge: is-it-maintained? #326)⚙️ Implementation Strategy
The PR took a layered approach to implementation:
This strategic implementation allowed for incremental improvement while maintaining project stability.
🌟 Conclusion
PR #330 represents a significant milestone in the evolution of the multicast project's quality assurance infrastructure. By consolidating multiple improvements into a cohesive framework, it establishes a foundation for more maintainable, secure, and well-tested code. The changes span testing, security, CI, documentation, and code style - touching nearly every aspect of the development lifecycle.
The comprehensive nature of this PR highlights the project's commitment to quality and provides clear guidelines for future contributions through the established patterns and tools. This work demonstrates the value of addressing technical debt systematically and laying a strong foundation for future development.
Summary by CodeRabbit
New Features
CI & Build
Documentation
Tests
Chores