Skip to content

Very different results from javascript. #14

Open
@choppsv1

Description

@choppsv1

The python code produces very different (and worrisome) results when compared to the javascript version. I use the python code in my change app to verify the password passes muster prior to changing it, so if anything I'd want it to be more strict that the client side JS version.

Password: FooBar2016
JS: score: 0, entropy: 18.541
Python: score: 2, entropy: 30.089

Password: ZagDag2016
JS: score: 2, entropy: 32.783
Python: score: 4, entropy: 44.264

If I had to choose I'd pick the JS version, the python one looks way too lenient.

(full result for FooBar2016 below.
JS:
Calling zxcvbn
{ password: 'FooBar2016',
entropy: 18.541,
match_sequence:
[ { pattern: 'dictionary',
i: 0,
j: 5,
token: 'FooBar',
matched_word: 'foobar',
rank: 908,
dictionary_name: 'passwords',
reversed: false,
base_entropy: 9.826548487290916,
uppercase_entropy: 4.392317422778761,
reversed_entropy: 0,
l33t_entropy: 0,
entropy: 14.218865910069677 },
{ pattern: 'regex',
token: '2016',
i: 6,
j: 9,
regex_name: 'recent_year',
regex_match: [Object],
entropy: 4.321928094887363 } ],
crack_time: 19.068,
crack_time_display: '19.068000000000023 seconds',
score: 0,
calc_time: 8 }

Python:

python -c 'import zxcvbn; print zxcvbn.password_strength("FooBar2016")'
{'crack_time_display': '17.0 hours', 'crack_time': 57103.66, 'score': 2, 'entropy': 30.089, 'password': 'FooBar2016', 'calc_time': 0.0005788803100585938, 'match_sequence': [{'l33t_entropy': 0, 'dictionary_name': 'passwords', 'matched_word': 'foobar', 'bas
e_entropy': 9.826548487290916, 'i': 0, 'pattern': 'dictionary', 'j': 5, 'rank': 908, 'token': 'FooBar', 'entropy': 14.285980105928214, 'uppercase_entropy': 4.459431618637297}, {'i': 6, 'pattern': 'spatial', 'j': 8, 'shifted_count': 0, 'token': '201', 'ent
ropy': 9.848831558033764, 'graph': 'keypad', 'turns': 2}, {'i': 9, 'pattern': 'bruteforce', 'j': 9, 'token': '6', 'entropy': 5.954196310386876, 'cardinality': 62}]}

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions