diff --git a/core/Error.cc b/core/Error.cc
index 8bc4df18f..4847172c4 100644
--- a/core/Error.cc
+++ b/core/Error.cc
@@ -123,8 +123,10 @@ string ErrorSection::toString(const GlobalState &gs) const {
 string Error::toString(const GlobalState &gs) const {
     stringstream buf;
     buf << RESET_STYLE << FILE_POS_STYLE << loc.filePosToString(gs) << RESET_STYLE << ": " << ERROR_COLOR
-        << restoreColors(header, ERROR_COLOR) << RESET_COLOR << LOW_NOISE_COLOR << " " << gs.errorUrlBase << what.code
-        << RESET_COLOR;
+        << restoreColors(header, ERROR_COLOR) << RESET_COLOR;
+    if (what.code != 25900) { // SCIPRubyDebug
+        buf << LOW_NOISE_COLOR << " " << gs.errorUrlBase << what.code << RESET_COLOR;
+    }
     if (loc.exists()) {
         auto fileLength = loc.file().data(gs).source().size();
         if (loc.beginPos() > fileLength || loc.endPos() > fileLength) {
diff --git a/core/GlobalState.cc b/core/GlobalState.cc
index 4b1ef1e9b..928cda9ef 100644
--- a/core/GlobalState.cc
+++ b/core/GlobalState.cc
@@ -1959,6 +1959,7 @@ unique_ptr<GlobalState> GlobalState::deepCopy(bool keepId) const {
     auto result = make_unique<GlobalState>(this->errorQueue, this->epochManager);
 
     result->silenceErrors = this->silenceErrors;
+    result->unsilenceErrors = this->unsilenceErrors;
     result->autocorrect = this->autocorrect;
     result->ensureCleanStrings = this->ensureCleanStrings;
     result->runningUnderAutogen = this->runningUnderAutogen;
@@ -2055,6 +2056,7 @@ unique_ptr<GlobalState> GlobalState::copyForIndex() const {
     result->files = this->files;
     result->fileRefByPath = this->fileRefByPath;
     result->silenceErrors = this->silenceErrors;
+    result->unsilenceErrors = this->unsilenceErrors;
     result->autocorrect = this->autocorrect;
     result->ensureCleanStrings = this->ensureCleanStrings;
     result->runningUnderAutogen = this->runningUnderAutogen;
@@ -2141,9 +2143,14 @@ bool GlobalState::shouldReportErrorOn(Loc loc, ErrorClass what) const {
     if (what.minLevel == StrictLevel::Internal) {
         return true;
     }
-    if (this->silenceErrors) {
+    if (this->silenceErrors && !this->unsilenceErrors) {
         return false;
     }
+    if (this->isSCIPRuby && !this->unsilenceErrors) {
+        if (what.code != 25900) { // SCIPRubyDebug
+            return false;
+        }
+    }
     if (suppressedErrorClasses.count(what.code) != 0) {
         return false;
     }
diff --git a/core/GlobalState.h b/core/GlobalState.h
index f7a7d726e..6ee1d739d 100644
--- a/core/GlobalState.h
+++ b/core/GlobalState.h
@@ -223,6 +223,7 @@ class GlobalState final {
 
     int globalStateId;
     bool silenceErrors = false;
+    bool unsilenceErrors = false;
     bool autocorrect = false;
 
     // We have a lot of internal names of form `<something>` that's chosen with `<` and `>` as you can't make
diff --git a/main/options/options.cc b/main/options/options.cc
index 573eeed81..905a90250 100644
--- a/main/options/options.cc
+++ b/main/options/options.cc
@@ -265,6 +265,7 @@ buildOptions(const vector<pipeline::semantic_extension::SemanticExtensionProvide
                           cxxopts::value<string>()->default_value(empty.inlineInput), "string");
     options.add_options()("files", "Input files", cxxopts::value<vector<string>>());
     options.add_options()("q,quiet", "Silence all non-critical errors");
+    options.add_options()("unquiet", "(scip-ruby) Show non-critical errors, which are hidden by default");
     options.add_options()("v,verbose", "Verbosity level [0-3]");
     options.add_options()("h", "Show short help");
     options.add_options()("help", "Show long help");
@@ -808,9 +809,14 @@ void readOptions(Options &opts,
         opts.stopAfterPhase = extractStopAfter(raw, logger);
 
         opts.silenceErrors = raw["quiet"].as<bool>();
+        opts.unsilenceErrors = raw["unquiet"].as<bool>();
+        if (opts.silenceErrors && opts.unsilenceErrors) {
+            logger->error("You can't pass both `{}` and `{}`", "--unquiet", "--quiet");
+            throw EarlyReturnWithCode(1);
+        }
         opts.autocorrect = raw["autocorrect"].as<bool>();
         opts.inlineInput = raw["e"].as<string>();
-        if (opts.autocorrect && opts.silenceErrors) {
+        if (opts.autocorrect && opts.silenceErrors && !opts.unsilenceErrors) {
             logger->error("You may not use autocorrect when silencing errors.");
             throw EarlyReturnWithCode(1);
         }
diff --git a/main/options/options.h b/main/options/options.h
index 3bf64c226..2fe5b0f60 100644
--- a/main/options/options.h
+++ b/main/options/options.h
@@ -156,6 +156,7 @@ struct Options {
     bool suggestTyped = false;
     std::optional<std::string> suggestUnsafe = std::nullopt;
     bool silenceErrors = false;
+    bool unsilenceErrors = false;
     bool silenceDevMessage = false;
     bool suggestSig = false;
     bool suppressNonCriticalErrors = false;
diff --git a/main/options/test/options_test.cc b/main/options/test/options_test.cc
index 866700399..0c1eabe5d 100644
--- a/main/options/test/options_test.cc
+++ b/main/options/test/options_test.cc
@@ -25,6 +25,7 @@ TEST_CASE("DefaultConstructorMatchesReadOptions") {
     CHECK_EQ(empty.showProgress, opts.showProgress);
     CHECK_EQ(empty.suggestTyped, opts.suggestTyped);
     CHECK_EQ(empty.silenceErrors, opts.silenceErrors);
+    CHECK_EQ(empty.unsilenceErrors, opts.unsilenceErrors);
     CHECK_EQ(empty.silenceDevMessage, opts.silenceDevMessage);
     CHECK_EQ(empty.suggestSig, opts.suggestSig);
     CHECK_EQ(empty.suppressNonCriticalErrors, opts.suppressNonCriticalErrors);
diff --git a/main/realmain.cc b/main/realmain.cc
index 368b5a847..ffe144bc2 100644
--- a/main/realmain.cc
+++ b/main/realmain.cc
@@ -488,6 +488,7 @@ int realmain(int argc, char *argv[]) {
     if (opts.silenceErrors) {
         gs->silenceErrors = true;
     }
+    gs->unsilenceErrors = opts.unsilenceErrors;
     if (opts.autocorrect) {
         gs->autocorrect = true;
     }
diff --git a/scip_indexer/Debug.cc b/scip_indexer/Debug.cc
index 1350b21ec..985f51137 100644
--- a/scip_indexer/Debug.cc
+++ b/scip_indexer/Debug.cc
@@ -8,7 +8,7 @@
 
 namespace sorbet::scip_indexer {
 
-constexpr sorbet::core::ErrorClass SCIPRubyDebug{400, sorbet::core::StrictLevel::False};
+constexpr sorbet::core::ErrorClass SCIPRubyDebug{25900, sorbet::core::StrictLevel::False};
 
 void _log_debug(const sorbet::core::GlobalState &gs, sorbet::core::Loc loc, std::string s) {
     if (auto e = gs.beginError(loc, SCIPRubyDebug)) {